ARTICLE

D3 Football: Bethel Coach on Playoff ‘Snub’ & Program Success

By: Eli Hershkovich | Published November 20, 2026 | 5 minutes read
D3 Football

Bethel D3 football finished the regular season with an 8-2 record, winning six consecutive games after opening with losses to nationally ranked North Central and Saint John’s. The Royals climbed from No. 52 to No. 33 in the NCAA Power Index (NPI) between Oct. 30 and Nov. 13.

Ultimately, they missed the 40-team Division III football playoff field, which included 29 automatic qualifiers and 11 at-large selections. Royals head coach Mike McElroy spoke with YD3 about the selection committee’s decision, the importance of scheduling challenging opponents and what success looks like beyond football.

Note: This Q&A has been edited for length and clarity.

D3 Football Scheduling & Turnaround

Q: Regarding the final pre-selection NPI update, Bethel improved 10 spots in the last week alone. What was your reaction when you learned the Royals had been left out?

McElory: It was a frustrating weekend. We had just finished the game against [College of St.] Scholastica on Saturday, and I was sitting in my office about an hour later when we found out we had been jumped. We felt like we were going to be in, and our seniors didn’t know whether that was their last game.

My issue is really with Division III football as a whole. What do we want to incentivize? Do we want big games, or do we want people to game the system?

We’ve seen closed conferences get three teams into the playoffs in two of the last three years. I’ve had coaches from other conferences reach out and ask why they don’t just close their conferences to avoid a snub. Our guys have played in two straight Elite Eight games, so having it end this way, especially when we thought we were in, was tough.

D3 Football

Q: Your team faced North Central and Saint John’s [in MIAC play], two nationally prominent programs, but lost both games. How do you balance that with the weight of the NPI?

McElroy: Our guys want to play those games. I want to play those games. We could go find teams we’re going to beat, but that’s not necessarily what’s best for our players or D3 football.

I think it’s important that we reward teams for scheduling good opponents. Imagine starting the season with more games like No. 1 versus No. 2 or No. 3 versus No. 5 instead of a bunch of blowouts because everybody is trying to get a win.

It’s getting harder and harder to create those types of matchups. When you take on those opponents, you also have to make sure the selection process recognizes the difficulty of that schedule. I’d rather play those competitive games than schedule a team just to get a win.

Q: After those two early losses, what will you remember most about this group?

I’m probably most proud of how we finished. Losing those two games can shake your confidence, but our guys rallied and won six straight, including a really good win against Concordia.

It was a testament to our senior leadership and the culture we’ve built. There were moments when we weren’t sure what the future held, but those guys kept battling. They care deeply about each other and about how we run this program.


Eligibility & Life Beyond D3 Football

Q: There’s been discussion about extending eligibility to a fifth year in Division III athletics. Given the graduate programs Bethel offers, how do you view the possibility for both student-athletes pursuing another degree and the sport’s competitive balance?

McElory: I would love that. We’re already having those conversations with [senior quarterback] Cooper Drews about what another year at Bethel University could look like if the proposal passes. If it doesn’t, there are opportunities for some of our guys to explore transferring to Division I programs.

D3 Football

I actually had a coach reach out just before this conversation to ask if we had any players interested in making that move.

I also think that, right now, when players transfer from other divisions, tracking down medical redshirt and eligibility documentation from several years ago can be incredibly difficult. A universal fifth-year rule would simplify that process and give more student-athletes the opportunity to continue playing.

We had a recent transfer from an FCS program, and we were calling a doctor from three years earlier, trying to track down medical paperwork.

If these kids want to come and compete, we need to make that process more equitable.

Q: We’ve previously talked about the balance between athletics, academics and professional development. How has senior running back David Geebli, who led the team in rushing yards, embodied that?

McElroy: David was working full days as a paraplanner intern at Newton Financial Solutions, sometimes starting at 7 a.m. and not finishing until late in the afternoon, before coming to practice.

D3 Football

We had about five seniors whose internships led to job opportunities, and some were working full-time while finishing a credit or two. It’s important for our younger guys to see that you can have success in football, do well academically and prepare for what’s next.

That’s what being a Division III student-athlete is all about.

Q: On Tuesday, Bethel University announced a historic $25 million gift to fund new soccer and softball facilities and support a proposed indoor training facility. What could it mean for Royals athletics moving forward?

McElory: I think it speaks to Bethel’s current momentum and its commitment to being really good at what we’re doing athletically. It’s really cool to see a family make that kind of investment and our leadership working to elevate Bethel athletics. You want to go to a place where people are serious about winning, the facilities and the overall experience.

We’re never trying to sell recruits on a place just because it has a cool stadium or a nice locker room. At the end of the day, it’s about the people you’re with and the relationships you build.

But these types of investments are game-changers because they demonstrate a commitment and a seriousness about making Bethel athletics really good. It shows that people are all-in on what we’re building here.

EH

Eli Hershkovich

Eli Hershkovich is the Head of Content at YD3. A sports journalist with over a decade of experience, Eli has covered professional and college sports for media organizations including Audacy and Sporting News. His work at YD3 Network combines original reporting and storytelling to explore the behind-the-scenes perspectives that define Division III athletics.

D3 Soccer

D3 Soccer: Inside Emory’s Third Straight Sweet 16 Journey

Mikayla Camp has helped Emory return to the D3 soccer Sweet 16 while managing the demands of postseason competition and rigorous academics.


Nov 20, 2026
D3 Field Hockey

D3 Field Hockey: Amherst Ends 27-Year Final Four Drought

Amherst has waited 27 years for another shot at the NCAA Final Four. Discover what’s fueling the Mammoths’ D3 field hockey push.


Nov 20, 2026
Fred Mitchell

Remembering Fred Mitchell: A Lasting Impact on D3 Football

Remembering Fred Mitchell, the longtime sportswriter whose work and contributions left a lasting mark on Division III football.


Nov 18, 2026